Our Ice Cream Pies are the perfect treat to get for yourself or to share with your friends, family, or coworkers year-round! Ice Cream Pies are made in a 9" pie tin with two layers of ice cream and a generous layer of toppings in between and on top. Each Ice Cream Pie can comfortably feed around 8-10 people depending on your slice size. The Ice Cream Pies will last for up to 4 months in the freezer. Since all of our pies are made-to-order, please give us 7 days notice prior to the pick up date to complete your order. Rush orders will have an additional fee.
When choosing your Ice Cream Pie, you can create a completely custom Ice Cream Pie where you choose your ice cream flavor(s) and the toppings that will go in between the ice cream layers, OR you can choose one of our Extreme Ice Cream flavors to be made into an Ice Cream Pie (see the Extreme Ice Cream choices on our Soft Serve Ice Cream page. Link to that page is below). If you choose an Extreme Ice Cream flavor to made into a pie, it will come with pre-determined toppings, but you can still choose your ice cream flavor(s).
Below are order forms for a Custom Ice Cream Pie OR an Extreme Ice Cream Pie. There is a separate form for each pie depending on if you wish to order a Custom Ice Cream Pie OR an Extreme Ice Cream Pie. Both are incredibly delicious choices! Please fill out the form that pertains to your choice of Ice Cream Pie.
If you have ANY questions, please send us a message via email through our Contact page and we will be in touch!
PIE OF THE MONTH
Each month we will be releasing a specialty Ice Cream Pie. We are so excited to be offering these flavors for a limited time only! Pie slices will be available for purchase in-store, only while supplies last. To order your pie of the month, fill out the form below or stop into our shop and we'd love to help you! Please order your Pie at least 2 days ahead of your pick up time. Rush orders will have an additional charge.
December Pie of the Month: Peppermint Fudgey Brownie $29.99
Oreo Pie Crust, Chocolate and White Chocolate Peppermint Ice Cream, Peppermint Chocolate bits, Brownie Bites, Chocolate Hardshell, and Fudge
December Pie Pick Up Dates: Friday 12/13 Saturday, 12/14 Sunday, 12/15 Friday, 12/20 Saturday, 12/21 Sunday, 12/22 Saturday, 12/28 Sunday, 12/29